In short
- Category creation is a positioning strategy for a product nobody sells yet: you teach buyers both the problem and a new kind of solution, and give the solution a name.
- It's the most expensive of the three strategies, because every conversation starts with education and nobody else is helping you explain it.
- It fits when there's truly no shelf for the product, and when the company has the time and resources for a long education effort.
- Most early-stage startups that think they need a new category are better served by teaching an existing one, or by winning the one buyers already know.
When I ran Yalla Marketing through my Positioning Builder, one of the paths it didn't choose was creating a new category. The reason was simple: the category already exists, with several established companies selling fixed-scope positioning projects under the same name.
It's a good example of how the decision usually goes: the market already has a shelf, even when the product feels new.
What category creation is
Category creation, sometimes called category design, is one of the three ways to place a product in the market. You decide the product belongs to a kind of solution nobody sells yet, you name it, and you teach buyers why they need it.
The other two positioning strategies work with a shelf that already exists: you either win in a market buyers already know, or you teach buyers a category that exists but they don't shop for yet. Category creation builds the shelf from scratch.
Every category starts as a job
Behind every B2B category there's a job people already do. Customer relationship management was something sales teams did with notebooks and spreadsheets long before it became CRM. A good category name is usually that job, turned into a noun.
That gives you a useful way to look at your own product. If it's a dedicated tool for a job people already do, the road is easier: the job exists, and you're giving it a better home. If it asks people to do something new, the road is much harder, because you have to create the job before anyone looks for a category to do it with.
What it costs
A new category means a young market, the least mature there is. Buyers don't know the problem has a name, they don't know there's a kind of product that solves it, and they don't have a budget line for it. Without a budget line, a buyer who loves the product still has nowhere to buy it from. More on that on the market maturity page.
So every sales call starts with education, the sales cycle is long, and there's no one else in the market helping you explain it. The homepage carries the same weight: before it can say why you're better, it has to explain why the problem matters at all.
That's why the resources question matters so much. In my own case, with one person doing the marketing and results needed within 12 months, even teaching an existing category was a stretch. Building a new one from scratch is a bigger bet.
When it fits
- There's truly no shelf. Buyers solve the problem with spreadsheets, people or nothing at all, and no company sells a product for it yet.
- The existing categories mislead. Every shelf you could stand on sets the wrong expectations, so being compared on it would hurt you.
- You can afford the time. The runway, the team and the patience to educate a market for a while before it buys.
Why most early-stage teams shouldn't start here
Founders often reach for a new category because their product feels different from everything else. That feeling is usually about the features, while the buyer still has a shelf in mind for the problem.
When the shelf exists, a new name forces the buyer to learn two things at once: what your category means, and why you're good at it. Picking the existing product category and teaching it, or winning in it on a clear differentiation, gets you to the buyer faster.
Large buyers add one more reason: in enterprise deals they'll still ask how you compare to known vendors, so even a new category needs a ready answer.
How to check before you decide
- Look at the competitive alternatives. If buyers compare a few known vendors, there's already a category. If they solve it with spreadsheets or freelancers, that's a sign you're teaching one, maybe a new one. The competitive alternatives page goes deeper.
- Listen to the sales calls. The words buyers use for the problem tell you which shelf is in their head.
- Ask an AI tool. Ask ChatGPT or Claude which companies sell what you have in mind. If the answer names vendors you'd recognize, the shelf is already there.
- Read the category phrase out loud. If a buyer can't tell from the name what the product does, the name needs a lot of budget behind it.
Where it's decided in the sprint
The positioning strategy is the last decision of session 1, after the target segment, its persona and the product category. My Builder suggests one of the three strategies from the competitor research, with its confidence and the reasons, and it explains the paths it didn't choose. The decision makers in the room make the call.
How does your own homepage score? Get a free homepage audit: your homepage scored on the same 7 dimensions of positioning, with a line from your own page behind each score. Free, private, never published.