Yalla Marketing

What is differentiation in positioning?

In short

  • Differentiation is what makes your product a better choice than the alternative your buyer uses today, for a specific buyer, in a way they can see.
  • It's measured against the real competitive alternatives, which are often a spreadsheet, a freelancer or an internal team, more than other vendors.
  • It carries the most weight in our homepage score: 25% of the total.
  • Being secure, easy to set up or well supported answers an objection. Those lines matter, and the buyer still needs a reason to pick you: that's the differentiation.

When we score a homepage, one question carries more weight than any other: can a buyer tell you apart from the alternative?

It gets 25% of the score, because a page can be clear about what the product is and still give the buyer no reason to pick it.

What differentiation is

Differentiation is what makes your product a better choice than the alternative, for a specific buyer. It answers the last of the four positioning questions: why is the product better than the alternative?

Two parts of that question do most of the work. Better than what, meaning the real competitive alternative. And better for whom, meaning your target segment. A difference that only matters to a buyer you don't sell to doesn't count.

Better than what you're really up against

The alternative is often something other than a competitor's product. It can be someone inside the company, an outside consultant, a course, a workshop, or a band-aid fix someone put together. It can also be the players whose names come up in your sales calls, the ones you lose deals to.

That changes what differentiation sounds like. Against a spreadsheet, the difference is what the spreadsheet can't do. Against a known vendor, it's the gap they leave open. So if your buyers compare you to two or three different alternatives, you'll need a slightly different answer for each one.

It also helps to decide early if you replace the alternative or work on top of it. Those are two different stories, and a page that tells both leaves the buyer unsure what you are.

Where it shows up in positioning

  • Choosing the segment. When we map segments, differentiation is one of the four criteria, next to severity, access and size. A segment where you're barely different from the alternative is a hard one to win, even when it's big.
  • Choosing the strategy. The positioning strategy is chosen by how mature the market is and where the gap from the competitors sits.
  • Choosing the USPs. In session 2 we rank your capabilities by how much the problem hurts the buyer today and how much of a wow factor each one is next to what they have now. The top three become your USPs.

A reason to buy, or an answer to an objection

A common pattern on early-stage homepages: the space right under the headline is filled with lines like secure, easy to set up, great support, integrates with everything. Those are answers to reasons not to buy. They matter, and they belong lower on the page, in the FAQ or a security section.

None of them tells the buyer why to choose you. When that's all the page offers, the buyer compares you on price.

Best for whom

"The best platform for X" tells a buyer nothing, because everyone says it. Think about how a good buying guide talks: best for small teams, best for regulated industries, best if you already use a certain tool. Differentiation works the same way. It's always better for a specific buyer, in a specific situation.

The same goes for AI. When AI is the first thing on your homepage, the buyer files you with every product that says it, and the next question is what yours does that theirs can't.

How to make it visible

  • Say it as what the buyer gets. The difference in the product, said as the result for the buyer. That's the value proposition.
  • Back it up. A named customer, a case study, a checkable number or a clear mechanism. More on the proof points page.
  • Name the alternative. When the page shows what the buyer compares you to, the difference has something to stand next to.

Where it's decided in the sprint

Session 2 is about why you win: the capabilities, the USPs and the value proposition, built on the segment and the competitive alternatives agreed in session 1. To see how your homepage scores on this question today, try the free homepage audit.

How does your own homepage score? Get a free homepage audit: your homepage scored on the same 7 dimensions of positioning, with a line from your own page behind each score. Free, private, never published.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

What is differentiation?

What makes your product a better choice than the alternative your buyer uses today, for a specific buyer, in a way they can see.

Who do I differentiate against?

Against the real competitive alternative: often a spreadsheet, a freelancer, an internal team or the vendors whose names come up in your sales calls.

Are security and ease of use differentiators?

Usually they answer a reason not to buy. They matter, and they belong lower on the page. The buyer still needs a reason to pick you, and that's the differentiation.

How does differentiation affect the homepage score?

Value differentiation is the heaviest of the seven dimensions, 25% of the score. It asks if a buyer can tell you apart from the alternative.

How do I make my differentiation visible?

Say it as what the buyer gets, back it up with proof like a named customer or a checkable number, and show what the buyer compares you to.

Yalla, let's talk

AI gave you superpowers. Your marketing still needs a brain

Yalla, let's talk