In short
- Competitive alternatives are what your buyer uses today instead of you: sometimes a competitor, and just as often someone in-house, an outside consultant, a course, or living with the problem.
- "Why we win" only means something next to that alternative, so positioning starts here.
- Be specific: "agencies" is a category, and the buyer is comparing you to one kind of agency.
- Your homepage should make it clear what you replace.
When I ask founders who they compete with, I usually get a list of startups. When I ask what their buyer does today, without them, the answer is much more interesting.
That second answer is your competitive alternative, and it's where positioning starts.
What counts as a competitive alternative
A competitive alternative is anything your buyer would use to solve the problem if your product didn't exist. It comes in two kinds.
The first kind is the competitors. These are the players whose names you hear in sales calls and lose deals to. If a name never comes up in a deal, it might be in your space, but it isn't your alternative.
The second kind is everything else, and it's often the bigger one:
- Someone in-house who handles it next to their real job.
- An outside consultant or agency.
- A course or a workshop that puts a band-aid on the problem, so the team feels better for a while.
- A spreadsheet, a manual process, or an old tool.
- Living with the problem for another year.
Why positioning starts from the alternative
"Better" is always better than something. A buyer can't judge your product in the abstract; they put it next to what they do today and ask if the switch is worth it.
That's why two of the four criteria we use to score segments are measured against the alternative. Severity asks how badly the problem with what they use today burns, how much it keeps them up at night. Differentiation asks how different they see you from that alternative. If the alternative works well enough, or you look just like it, the segment isn't yours yet.
Be specific about the alternative
"Agencies" is one of the most common answers I hear, and it's too wide to write from. When you say agencies, what do you mean? A performance agency that runs ads, a content agency, a branding studio? Each one fails the buyer in a different way, so each one needs a different answer to "why us?".
The same goes for "they do it in-house". Who does it, with what, and what goes wrong? The more specific the alternative, the sharper the message you can write against it.
Different segments often have different alternatives. That's one more reason to pick one segment to start with: you can't write a clear "why us" against five alternatives at once.
Replace it, or work next to it?
One more decision belongs here: does the buyer drop the alternative and use you instead, or keep it and add you on top? "Switch, and stop paying for the old tool" and "make the tool you already have work better" are two different value propositions. Many teams tell the first story to one buyer and the second to another, and the homepage ends up telling both, so decide before you write.
If you replace it, look at everything around the old tool too: the integrations, the data inside it, the people trained on it and the processes built around it. That's what the buyer really gives up when they switch. A buyer who complains about the current tool is a good start. The more that's built around it, the more clearly better you need to be before anyone moves.
Where it shows up on your homepage
When we score a homepage, two of the seven dimensions are about the alternative. Competitive context asks if the page says what the buyer compares you to. Value differentiation, the dimension with the most weight, asks if a buyer can tell you apart from the alternative.
A page can do this without naming a single competitor. "Instead of a three-month agency project" or "without hiring a full-time marketer" tells the buyer exactly what you replace. You can see how the strongest homepages do it in the homepage scores gallery, or get your own page scored with the free homepage audit.
How we map alternatives in the sprint
Before session 1, my Positioning Builder researches your competitors, so we start from what we already know about your market. In session 1, every segment we map gets its alternative and the problem with it, in the founders' words. By the time we pick a segment, we know exactly what we're up against, and that's what the USPs and the value proposition are written against in session 2.
How does your own homepage score? Get a free homepage audit: your homepage scored on the same 7 dimensions of positioning, with a line from your own page behind each score. Free, private, never published.