In short
- A positioning consultant helps the founders make the positioning decisions (who you focus on, what you are, what you're compared to and why you win) and writes them down so the website, the sales pitch and the AI tools all use the same ones.
- You should leave with decisions and finished text: locked positioning, a messaging doc, website copy and a marketing brain your tools can read.
- My sprint takes three weeks. Whatever the length, ask for a fixed scope and an end date.
- Consultant, agency or doing it yourself depends first on one thing: whether the founders already agree on the answers.
I've sat in a few of the seats founders hire for marketing: VP Marketing, CMO, fractional CMO, and two years at an agency. In every startup I worked with, I built the marketing from zero, and I always started with the positioning.
Today the positioning is the whole job. I work with founders on that part only, in a three-week sprint with a fixed scope.
What a positioning consultant does
A positioning consultant runs the process that gets the founders to a few hard decisions: which segment you focus on first, its persona, your product category, your positioning strategy, and why you win. Then they write the decisions down in a form the whole team can use.
The founders know their buyer and their market. The consultant brings the method, the distance to ask the uncomfortable question, and a way to get everyone who decides to agree. In my sessions the method starts with scoring: each segment gets a score on four criteria (severity, differentiation, access and size) before anyone picks one. After the decision, the consultant's job is to keep the bet locked for about half a year, long enough to learn from what the market sends back.
Knowing your industry is not on that list. Positioning is vertical-agnostic, and I explain why in Does your positioning consultant need to know your industry?
What you should get at the end
Decisions, and the text built on them:
- Locked positioning. The segment, persona, category, strategy and why you win, agreed by everyone who decides and written down in one place. More on the locked positioning page.
- A messaging doc. One value proposition, three USPs, the boilerplate, the elevator pitch, the homepage hero and the objection handling your salespeople use. The messaging doc page shows what goes in it.
- Website copy. The homepage, the product page and the FAQ, written from the messaging doc and ready to ship, starting with the homepage hero.
- A marketing brain. All of it in plain files your team owns, so every AI tool writes from the same decisions. See marketing brain.
Ask for the copy as part of the project. When it ends with recommendations and someone else writes the pages later, there are weeks of back and forth, and the copy drifts away from what you decided.
A simple check when it's over: ask each founder the four positioning questions separately. The answers should match each other, and they should match your new homepage.
How long it should take
The positioning process I always ran used to take me about three months, plus a content writer. Once I turned it into my Positioning Builder, the same work takes three weeks: three two-hour sessions, one a week, with the drafting in between. Your team's time is those three sessions and the onboarding questionnaire.
Whatever the length, ask for a fixed scope and an end date in the contract, so you know exactly what you get and when. The decisions also need a few sessions with time in between to settle, and the positioning workshop page explains why one long day rarely holds.
Consultant, agency or doing it yourself
All three can work. Start by asking whether the founders already agree.
- Doing it yourself fits when every founder already gives the same four answers. Then the job is writing the decisions down, and AI tools help a lot with that. When the founders don't agree, AI writes whichever version it's given, and Can ChatGPT or Claude write your positioning? covers that case.
- An agency fits once the positioning is decided and the job is producing: a brand, a website, campaigns. Each of them works best on decisions that are already made.
- A consultant fits when the open question is the positioning itself: one senior person who runs the decisions with the founders and hands over finished text. For ongoing leadership after that, a fractional CMO or a first hire builds on what's decided.
How my sprint runs
Before session 1, my Builder reads your questionnaire, the competitor research and your demo and prospect call recordings. In session 1 everyone who decides picks the segment, its persona, your product category and your positioning strategy. Session 2 sets why you win: the capabilities, the three USPs, the value proposition, the KPIs and your tone of voice. In session 3 we review the messaging and the website copy together, section by section. After your last edits you get your marketing brain, ready for your AI tools. The full schedule is on How it works.
How does your own homepage score? Get a free homepage audit: your homepage scored on the same 7 dimensions of positioning, with a line from your own page behind each score. Free, private, never published.