In short
- Competitor research is mapping who else your buyers consider, what they say, and where they leave a gap you can own.
- Sort competitors by what happens in deals: the ones you meet, the ones you lose to, and the ones that aren't relevant.
- The competitors you choose to compare yourself to decide where buyers place you.
- Use the research to make decisions, then find what only you can say.
Most startups have a competitor slide. Five logos, a two-by-two chart with the company in the top right corner, and not much else. It's made for investors, and it rarely helps write a homepage.
Competitor research for positioning has a different job.
What competitor research is for
For positioning, competitor research answers three questions: who else does the buyer consider, how do they describe themselves, and where is the gap they leave open. The answers feed your positioning strategy, your USPs and the words you use.
It's also part of a bigger picture. Competitors are only one kind of competitive alternative. Your buyer might also use a spreadsheet, an agency or nothing at all.
Sort them by what happens in deals
A long list of companies in your space isn't useful by itself. I sort competitors by what happens in real sales conversations:
- You meet them. Their names come up on calls, and buyers compare you.
- You lose to them. They win deals you wanted. These matter most.
- Not relevant. They're in your space on paper, and they never come up with your buyers.
When the founders can't agree which bucket a company belongs in, that's a useful conversation. It usually means each of them is selling to a different segment, and the competitor list is just where it shows.
The companies whose names you hear in sales calls and lose deals to are your real competition. A company that never comes up in a deal can drop off the list, however big it is.
Your competitors define where you stand
The competitors you compare yourself to decide where buyers place you. Line up next to enterprise platforms and you'll be judged as one, on price and features. Line up next to agencies and you'll be judged as a service. Choosing the comparison is part of choosing your product category.
How much competitors should shape your story
That depends on the strategy. When you teach buyers a category they don't shop for yet, they may not know the other companies in it, so the research is mostly for your own decisions, and the page talks about how buyers do the job today.
When you win in a market buyers already know and it has a clear leader, buyers already compare everyone to it, so your story says where you're different from the leader, and for which buyers the leader is the wrong fit. The research there goes deep on the leader: what its customers complain about, which kind of company it serves poorly, and where your product does the job better.
It's one of the things we weigh when we pick your positioning strategy in session 1, together with market maturity.
What to collect
For each competitor that matters:
- How they describe themselves: their homepage headline, category and audience.
- Who they're really for, judging by their customers and case studies.
- What they claim, and what proof they show.
- Where buyers complain: reviews, sales calls, the reasons people switched.
Then look for the gap: a buyer they ignore, a job they do badly, a claim nobody can prove.
Use it to decide, then write your own
It's tempting to read competitors' sites and write a better version of their copy. Then your page sounds like theirs. The research shows you what everyone else says, so you can decide what only you can say.
Before and during session 1
Before session 1, my Positioning Builder researches your competitors, so we start from what we already know about your market. In session 1 the founders go through the list, sort it by what they see in deals, and fill the gaps. From there, every segment we map has its alternative and the problem with it.
How does your own homepage score? Get a free homepage audit: your homepage scored on the same 7 dimensions of positioning, with a line from your own page behind each score. Free, private, never published.