In short
- Rebranding is changing how your company looks and sounds: the name, the logo, the visual identity, the website design and often the voice.
- A rebrand changes the packaging. Repositioning changes what you sell, to whom and why you win.
- When a startup says "we need a rebrand", it often needs repositioning first.
- The right order: positioning, then messaging, then the brand, then the website.
"Our brand feels outdated, we need a rebrand." It's a common request, and sometimes it's right. Often the logo isn't what's bothering the founders.
What's bothering them is that the company doesn't land, and the brand is the most visible thing to change.
What rebranding is
Rebranding is changing how your company looks and sounds: the name, the logo, the colors and type, the website design, and often the tone of voice. It's the packaging of the company, everything a buyer sees before they read a word.
Rebranding and repositioning
The two get mixed up all the time, and they solve different problems.
Repositioning changes the decisions: what you sell, to whom, against what, and why you win. It's what you need when the market moved, the product changed, or the buyers you win aren't the ones your site speaks to.
Rebranding changes the expression of those decisions. It's what you need when the positioning is right and the look no longer fits it, or never did.
A new logo on unclear positioning gives you the same confusion with better colors.
The right order
In the startups where I led a rebrand, it came after the positioning and the messaging. We defined who the company is for and why it wins first, and the rebrand and the website were built on that. Some of those founders describe the process in their own words on my homepage. The order looks like this:
- Positioning first. Lock the segment, the alternative and why you win.
- Then messaging. The value proposition, the three USPs and the voice.
- Then the brand. A visual identity that expresses those decisions, so the designer has something to design for.
- Then the website. Copy from the messaging, design from the brand.
A designer briefed on locked positioning has something to design for, because the brief says who the brand is for and what it should make them feel.
Signs you need repositioning, not a rebrand
- The founders describe the company differently from each other.
- You rewrite the homepage every quarter.
- Buyers like the demo and still don't get what you are from the site.
- The product has changed and the site describes the old one.
If two or more of these sound familiar, start with the positioning. The brand can follow.
Careful with new labels
A rebrand sometimes renames the category too: a fresh phrase that sounds bigger than "software for X" and that the team likes in the presentation. Buyers look for what they need in their own plain words, and a label they've never heard makes them work to figure out if it's for them. Unless the positioning chose to create a new category, keep the plain product category your buyers already use and let the design carry the personality.
Before you brief a designer
A good brand brief answers a few questions the designer can't answer alone: who the brand is for, what it should make them feel, what it must never look like, and which competitors it has to stand apart from. Those answers come from the positioning, the messaging and the tone of voice. Without them, the brief turns into a mood board and the brand into a matter of taste.
The positioning sprint covers the first two steps and the website copy: in 3 weeks we lock your positioning, set the value proposition, the three USPs and the tone of voice in session 2, and review the messaging and your website copy in session 3. If a rebrand comes next, your designer starts from locked decisions.
How does your own homepage score? Get a free homepage audit: your homepage scored on the same 7 dimensions of positioning, with a line from your own page behind each score. Free, private, never published.