In short
- A case study is the story of one customer: the problem they had, what they did with you, and what changed, with proof.
- The best case study is about a customer in the segment you're selling to, because buyers look for someone like them.
- A strong case study has a before, an after, a number and a named person, with their consent.
- A famous logo from the wrong segment makes a nice slide and rarely helps sell.
A big logo from the wrong segment can look like a great case study and still do little for you. It won't help you sell to the segment you want to grow in.
And a case study helps only when the buyer reading it sees their own company in it.
What a case study is
A case study tells the story of one customer: who they are, what problem they had, what they used before, what they did with you, and what changed. It's one of the strongest proof points a B2B company can have, because it shows the product working for a real company.
Buyers look for someone like them
A buyer reading a case study asks one question: is this company like mine? Same size, same industry, same problem, same kind of team. If the answer is yes, the story is evidence. If not, it's a nice story about someone else.
That's why the case studies worth collecting first are the ones from your target segment. One case study from a company your buyers recognize as a peer does more than three from big names in other markets.
What a strong case study includes
- The situation. Who the customer is, and what they were dealing with.
- The alternative. What they used or did before, and why it wasn't enough.
- What they did. How they used the product, in concrete steps.
- The result. A before and after, with a number where there is one.
- A named voice. A quote from a person with a name and a title.
The number and the name are the hardest parts to get. They're also what makes a buyer believe it.
Put the result at the top. Many buyers read only the headline and the first line, so the before and after, with its number, goes there, and the story follows for whoever wants to know how it happened. In the story itself, the decisions are often the part that convinces: what the customer considered, what they chose and what they gave up for it. A buyer facing the same choice is looking for exactly that.
Consent first
A customer's name, logo, quote or numbers go public only when they agree. Until then, the story can still be told without the name, as long as it stays true: "a B2B software company in logistics" instead of the real name, with the real numbers. I keep the same rule for my own proof: the client stays unnamed until they agree, and the numbers stay real.
When you don't have one yet
Early-stage startups often have no finished case study. Use what you have: a design partner's quote about why they joined, a pilot with a clear starting point, a short before and after from one team. Plan the case study from the start of a project, with a baseline you measure early, so there's an after to compare it to.
Case studies and positioning
A case study repeats your positioning through a customer's eyes: the segment, the alternative, why you won. When the positioning is locked, you know which customers to ask and what story to tell. When it's open, you end up with case studies that each describe a slightly different company.
How does your own homepage score? Get a free homepage audit: your homepage scored on the same 7 dimensions of positioning, with a line from your own page behind each score. Free, private, never published.